Mauricio Pochettino’s first game as Manchester United head coach was lost inside 13 minutes at Anfield. Leny Yoro was sent off after eight, Dominik Szoboszlai scored the free-kick, Florian Wirtz added an acrobatic second, and Liverpool won 4-0 against ten men. Our Man Utd player ratings vs Liverpool have Harry Maguire as the best of a bad lot, which says plenty about Pochettino’s first team sheet. The centre-back he left on the bench was the only defender who did his job, and he has to start against Brentford on Saturday.

Earlier on this fixture: Yoro red card: the ban that rules him out of Brentford (22 November), Liverpool vs Man Utd confirmed lineups: Maguire benched, De Ligt starts (22 November) and Liverpool vs Man Utd lineups and team news (20 November).

Player Rating In one line
Harry Maguire (on 22′) 7 Top rated. Two goal-saving blocks and 14 clearances, blocks and interceptions
Senne Lammens 6 Seven saves, beaten four times without much chance
Kobbie Mainoo 6 Kept winning the ball and made United’s best pass
Youri Tielemans 5 Five tackles and United’s best first-half shot
Bruno Fernandes 5 Never stopped running, never threatened Alisson
Bryan Mbeumo 4 Sacrificed after 22 minutes
Patrick Dorgu 4 Chased shadows for 64 minutes
Matheus Cunha 4 Isolated, then hooked at half-time
Joshua Zirkzee (on 46′) 4 One long-range shot, little else
Mason Mount (on 65′) 4 No impact in 25 minutes
Noussair Mazraoui (on 65′) 4 On a minute before the third went in
Diogo Dalot 3 Ngumoha beat him for the second goal and kept beating him
Matthijs de Ligt 3 Misjudged the ball that led to the red card
Lisandro Martinez 3 Left behind by Barcola for the third
Leny Yoro 2 Lowest rated. Sent off after eight minutes
Andrey Santos (on 87′) – Not on long enough to rate

Man Utd player ratings vs Liverpool, player by player

Senne Lammens 6: Made seven saves, including two in a few seconds on 75 minutes, from Alexander Isak and then a 20-yard effort from Szoboszlai. He couldn’t do anything about the four goals, though Bruno Fernandes had a shout at him straight after the free-kick.

Diogo Dalot 3: Rio Ngumoha went past him to cross for Wirtz’s goal and then did it again and again. Dalot also hurt his arm in an awkward landing before half-time and played on.

Leny Yoro 2: Isak’s first touch was heavy and the ball might have reached Lammens, but Yoro bundled him over just outside the box anyway. Sam Barrott sent him off with seven minutes and 23 seconds on the clock, United’s earliest red card in the Premier League, and he misses Brentford.

Matthijs de Ligt 3: His first Premier League start in 357 days began with him misreading the long ball that put Isak through for the red card. On 63 minutes a bad misjudgement left him stumbling, and Isak should have scored. He did head a Fernandes corner just wide.

Lisandro Martinez 3: Bradley Barcola ran at him from halfway on 66 minutes and left him behind before setting up Ngumoha’s goal.

Kobbie Mainoo 6: United’s best player on the ball. On 59 minutes he won it back and slid a lovely pass through for Fernandes, who didn’t have the pace to get away from Jeremy Jacquet. His 15 defensive contributions in official FPL data were the most of anyone on the pitch.

Youri Tielemans 5: Made five tackles in 64 minutes, and his deflected shot on 35 minutes, which looped onto the roof of the net, was United’s best moment of the first half.

Bryan Mbeumo 4: Lost a simple ball out of play early on and had a penalty claim against Jacquet checked and turned down. Then he was the one taken off when Pochettino needed another centre-back.

Bruno Fernandes 5: Curled a free-kick just wide on five minutes, then rolled a soft shot to Alisson and, in stoppage time, forced the goalkeeper’s only proper save of the afternoon. He kept going to the end, which is more than most of his teammates did.

Patrick Dorgu 4: Two tackles in 64 minutes, by the official FPL count, and no impact going forward before he went off.

Matheus Cunha 4: Won a couple of free-kicks and had nobody near him. He went off at half-time.

Substitutes: Harry Maguire 7, Joshua Zirkzee 4, Mason Mount 4, Noussair Mazraoui 4, Andrey Santos not rated. Maguire’s block on 40 minutes stopped a near-certain third from Isak after he turned in the box, and in stoppage time he got in front of Virgil van Dijk’s header back across goal. Zirkzee’s 25-yard effort early in the second half took a deflection for a corner and that was his afternoon.

Thirteen minutes that settled it

Everything that went wrong happened before United had settled. One long ball over the defence, De Ligt caught under it, Yoro chasing Isak, and a red card. Sky Sports’ match report called the decision controversial because Isak seemed to have lost control, and Mainoo was blunter when Sky asked him afterwards whether it was a red card: “No chance. The ball’s already with the keeper, they’re both running full speed, what can he do?” It was a harsh one, but a defender who bundles a striker over just outside the box hands the referee the decision. Szoboszlai bent the free-kick into the bottom corner, and two minutes and 46 seconds later Wirtz turned Ngumoha’s cross from the left in off the crossbar.

Pochettino’s answer was Maguire for Mbeumo on 22 minutes and a back five. It stopped the bleeding for the rest of the half, and it cost United their outlet. Mbeumo was United’s one runner in behind, and without him Cunha was alone against van Dijk and Jacquet. Cunha lasted until half-time. By 56 minutes Liverpool had made 50 passes into the final third in the second half and United had made one.

Liverpool finished with 4.38 expected goals to United’s 0.63 and 60 touches in the United box to nine. Liverpool could have had more: Barcola missed three good chances, Isak lashed one wide after De Ligt’s second mistake and Lammens kept them out seven times.

Pochettino owns the selection. Before kick-off he told Sky Sports: “We believe that is the best starting 11 for today.” He picked De Ligt and Yoro ahead of Maguire, and the man he left out made 14 clearances, blocks and interceptions in 68 minutes, more than any other player in the match by that count in official FPL data.

The result leaves United 19th, a point off the bottom, and the first time since November 1986 they have been in the bottom two after ten or more games, according to BBC Sport. That was the month Ron Atkinson was sacked and Alex Ferguson arrived. They have now conceded 34 goals in all competitions. Liverpool go fourth, a point behind Manchester City and seven behind Arsenal.

With Yoro suspended, Brentford come to Old Trafford on Saturday 28 November at 15:00, and Maguire has to start next to Martinez whatever Pochettino thinks of De Ligt. The bigger question is whether Fernandes, who told Sky before the game that it isn’t the right moment to talk about his contract, gets more help from the players around him than he did here. FPL managers holding United defenders should look at the GW12 to GW16 fixture run before Friday’s 18:30 deadline.

Featured photo: Ardfern, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped).

Arjun Rao is a football writer covering the Premier League for The False 9 — tactical breakdowns, transfer analysis and the numbers behind the game.