Pochettino's arrival gives Man Utd's attackers a fresh look, but the back line is the problem. Fantasy managers should wait for evidence before backing the defence.

Mauricio Pochettino has been appointed Manchester United's head coach, taking over from Michael Carrick, who was sacked earlier this week with the Red Devils sitting in the bottom three. For Fantasy managers, the question is whether a new coach can quickly turn United's assets back into points. My read is that the attack has a clearer path to improvement than the defence, and that the early fixtures will tell us less than we'd like.
A tough start, then a kind run
United's first match under Pochettino is away at Liverpool after the international break. That's a difficult opening, and it's made tougher by his timing. He won't take charge until Wednesday because of his commitments with the US national team, which leaves three days at most to work with his new squad before the trip to Anfield.
The fixtures after that look better. Across the next four Gameweeks, United rank third for fixture difficulty, facing Brentford, Newcastle United, Coventry City and Crystal Palace. Managers planning a Gameweek 14 Free Hit could look at United's players for the home game against Coventry, provided they've shown enough under the new coach to justify the transfer.

The defence is the problem
Only Ipswich Town and Crystal Palace have conceded more than United's 19 league goals this season, and neither has kept a clean sheet. That's the headline figure, and it's hard to build a Fantasy case around any United defender until it changes.
Can Pochettino fix it? Chelsea's 2023/24 season gives a cautious answer. His side conceded 63 times in 38 league matches, ranked mid-table for expected goals conceded (xGC, 58.9) and recorded only eight clean sheets. Liam Twomey, a Chelsea writer, put it bluntly in a recent piece for The Athletic:
"They were really exciting when they had the ball, but it's not fun to watch your team defend incompetently, as Chelsea often did under Pochettino, while making unforced errors. To some extent, you can put that on the Chelsea players, but Enzo Maresca got them to defend at a much higher level, albeit with a less exciting style of football. Some of their defensive struggles were baked into what Pochettino wanted to do." – Liam Twomey, The Athletic
That's the uncomfortable part. If the defensive looseness is built into how Pochettino wants his team to play, United's back line may not tighten quickly, whatever the squad's quality. Defensive returns are the biggest thing I'd wait on.
Full-backs: width first, points second
Pochettino typically relies on his full-backs for width, which makes this one to monitor. His record suggests they can contribute. At Tottenham Hotspur in 2017/18, Ben Davies (£3.9m) and Kieran Trippier each supplied seven assists, finishing first and second among defenders for chances created. More recently, Malo Gusto (£4.8m) produced six assists under Pochettino in 2023/24. Sergino Dest also looked a real threat down the right for the US at last summer's World Cup.
United's current options are a different story. Diogo Dalot (£4.7m) is out of form, and Luke Shaw (£4.2m) has started only five league games because of injury.
Above: How Man Utd have used their full-backs so far this season
Patrick Dorgu (£5.7m) offers the most energy. He scored and assisted off the bench against Aston Villa before the international break, and his dynamism could make him a candidate to start over Shaw. The catch is that he's classed as a midfielder in FPL, which blunts his appeal for managers who want a defensive asset.
If United do tighten up, the defensive contribution (DefCon) points for centre-backs will matter more than clean sheets alone. As a benchmark, Thiago Silva would hypothetically have led Pochettino's Chelsea backline for DefCons, with a 29% hit rate.
A 4-2-3-1 with room to move
Expect a 4-2-3-1. It's the shape Pochettino favoured at Southampton, Tottenham and Chelsea, and it gives his attacking players a clear structure. He isn't rigid, though. He has used a back three before, and at Paris Saint-Germain he ran a 4-3-3 that had to accommodate Lionel Messi, Neymar and Kylian Mbappé. With the US national team, he built a hybrid back three/four to get the most from his wing-backs, where he had greater depth.

Above: Chelsea's average position map v Bournemouth in 2023/24, Pochettino's final match in charge, featuring Cole Palmer (No 20)
That flexibility matters because United's personnel will shape the system more than the coach's preferences. Watch the first few lineups closely for signs of which template he settles on.
Attacking football should suit United's forwards
Pochettino is known for high-intensity, attacking football built on heavy pressing. His Chelsea side scored 77 goals in 38 league matches in 2023/24 and created 122 big chances, just two fewer than champions Manchester City. Cole Palmer (£9.8m) was the main beneficiary, with 22 goals and 13 assists in 29 starts and a handful of substitute appearances. Nicolas Jackson (£7.1m) also had plenty of chances to work with.

Above: Chelsea players sorted by expected goal involvement (xGI) in 2023/24
Twomey again pointed to that record of backing forwards:
"The best thing about Pochettino at Chelsea was how he gave a platform to young players, such as Cole Palmer and Nicolas Jackson. He goes to great lengths to create a positive environment for his players, especially attackers." – Liam Twomey, The Athletic
Bruno Fernandes (£11.6m) remains the obvious starting point. He takes the penalties in the No 10 role, and while he's been well below his best for much of the season, he still has six attacking returns from nine matches. He has also created 23 chances, the fourth-most of any player. A coach who gives attackers a clearer structure could bring that form back.
The narrow positions Pochettino's wingers tend to occupy should suit Bryan Mbeumo (£7.9m) and Matheus Cunha (£7.8m). Both are likely to operate close to Fernandes and the central striker, which is where chances are generated. Pochettino has also spoken fondly of Marcus Rashford (£6.8m) in the past. Could Rashford be a makeshift No 9 until Benjamin Sesko (£6.9m) returns from injury? Mbeumo or Cunha could lead the line too, so there are options.
Youth, and a dependable DefCon candidate
Pochettino tends to favour younger players, from Shaw at Southampton to Dele Alli at Tottenham and Palmer at Chelsea. That could mean more minutes for Kobbie Mainoo (£5.5m), who has arguably been United's best player so far this season and is a regular DefCon contributor.
Leny Yoro (£4.8m), Carlos Baleba (£4.9m), Andrey Santos (£4.7m), Shea Lacey (£4.9m) and Amad Diallo (£5.7m) are other young options who could bring the energy Pochettino wants. Of that group, I'd keep the closest eye on Diallo and Mainoo once the minutes settle.
Where this leaves Fantasy managers

Pochettino could be a strong fit for United, but from a Fantasy perspective, we need to see how the system develops before committing. A trip to Anfield next weekend, followed by a Champions League tie with Sporting, gives us a couple of matches to judge the set-up before the fixtures get easier.
The defence is by far the biggest concern, and the Chelsea evidence doesn't offer much reassurance. The attack is where the early upside lies. Fernandes has plenty of potential as a roaming No 10, and Mbeumo and Cunha could attract interest as the system beds in.
That said, the real test is whether this squad can press at the intensity Pochettino demands across the pitch, from the first whistle to the last. Whether United have the attributes to do that in the early weeks is still an open question, and that's the one I'd keep watching.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.